I bought the travel size set, so I could smell all of them before committing to one, or two 😉
Overall, my favorite is Malibu Peach, followed bySychelles Sand- a vanilla musk scent, then Kaanapali Coast - a coconut vanilla scent. This one smells a bit sharp to me, the others are warm and inviting, but Marbella Bloom - renamed to Pink Peony, is my least favorite. With a name like Pink Peony I expected a warm creamy rose scent, which this is not that.