So I found this at my local Ulta, I smelled all 4 and this one was the best smelling of them all. I have used it so many times now because this stuff performs like a perfume and not like a body mist! I have been stopped by multiple people to ask what I am wearing and to tell me how amazing I smell! I have been told I smell like a warm cupcake and I have also been told it smells like the perfect cozy gourmand. I honestly agree with them, there is a creamy note to this, not overly laconic but just the perfect amount of creamy to it, it is musky but not overly musky either and I get the perfect amount of Vanilla and spice. This is perfect for any time of year, I do feel like I am going to love this for fall and winter. 100/10, please keep this as a permanent item!!